top of page

Alternate History Forums: Where to Discuss and Explore "What If" Scenarios

Updated: May 3

Alternate history is a captivating genre that allows us to explore the fascinating question of "what if?" It's a realm where historians and fiction writers come together to reimagine historical events and consider how the world might have unfolded differently. While some historians may shy away from this speculative exploration, there is a vibrant community of enthusiasts who love discussing and debating alternate history scenarios.


In this blog post, we will delve into the top three platforms where you can find engaging alternate history discussions: Reddit, Quora, and the forum alternatehistory.com. Additionally, we will explore how alternate history fandom has its place on the internet, providing a wealth of information and resources for enthusiasts. Let's dive in!


Reddit: A Hub for Alternate History Enthusiasts


Reddit is a popular online platform known for its passionate communities dedicated to a wide range of topics. It's no surprise that alternate history enthusiasts have found their home on Reddit as well. Within the subreddit r/HistoryWhatIf, you can find engaging discussions on various alternate history scenarios. One particular thread that caught my attention explores what would have happened if Joseph Stalin had died in August 1941. It's fascinating to see how different perspectives and analyses shape the alternate history narrative, providing unique insights into the potential consequences of such a scenario.


Quora: Where "What-If" Questions Thrive


Quora is a question-and-answer platform where users can seek knowledge, share insights, and discuss various topics. It's a great place to find thought-provoking "what-if" questions about alternate history. Many Quora users have posed questions about the fall of Britain during World War II, a topic that has also been explored in top alternate history books like SS-GB and Resistance. Exploring these discussions can shed light on the potential outcomes of alternate historical events and provide valuable insights into the complexities of the past.


A battle map showing the planned Nazi invasion of Great Britain called Operation Sea Lion.
The planned invasion of Great Britain by Nazi Germany (Operation Sea Lion).


alternatehistory.com: The Forum for Alternate History Enthusiasts


If you're looking for a dedicated platform solely focused on alternate history, look no further than alternatehistory.com. This forum hosts a vibrant community of history enthusiasts who engage in in-depth discussions about alternate history scenarios. One intriguing topic that I plan to explore in my Kaiser's Machines timeline is the hypothetical death of FDR in the 1930s. The discussions on alternatehistory.com offer a wealth of knowledge and diverse perspectives, making it an excellent resource for anyone interested in delving deeper into the intricacies of alternate history.


Alternate History Fandom: A Wiki for Enthusiasts


While not a forum in the traditional sense, Alternate History Fandom is a wiki-hosting service that provides a wealth of information and resources for alternate history enthusiasts. This wiki covers various alternate history topics, allowing users to explore different scenarios and timelines. One fascinating example is the wiki page dedicated to "Hitler's Britain," which presents an alternate history where Nazi Germany successfully invaded and occupied Britain. These wikis offer a comprehensive overview of various alternate history scenarios and serve as a valuable resource for enthusiasts seeking to deepen their understanding of this genre.


Why Alternate History Captivates Us


The popularity of alternate history can be attributed to its ability to capture our imagination and spark curiosity. It appeals to many individuals, from amateur historians and hobbyists to professional historians and writers. By exploring alternative scenarios, we gain a deeper appreciation for the actual historical events that shaped our world. It allows us to consider the consequences of pivotal historical moments and reflect on how different choices could have led to vastly different outcomes. In a way, alternate history reminds us of the fragility of historical events and the significant impact they have on our present and future.


bottom of page